
1 Hotel Central Park
Best for eco-focused travelers who want modern design, contemporary dining, and Midtown walkability.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
1 Hotel Central Park is a contemporary, sustainability-minded luxury hotel steps from Central Park and Midtown cultural sites; this guide is for travelers who want modern design, eco-features, and easy access to Broadway and shopping. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a storied Upper East Side 5-star with old-New-York service and celebrity history; read this if you prefer classic, residential luxury and a clubby downtown alternative to Midtown.
Updated · about 1.2 miles (1.9 km) apart

Best for eco-focused travelers who want modern design, contemporary dining, and Midtown walkability.

Best for guests who want old-New-York service, a polished Upper East Side address, and a classic Rosewood stay.
When 1 Hotel Central Park wins: choose 1 Hotel for a contemporary, sustainably minded stay with direct Midtown access, a lively modern restaurant (Jams), a 24-hour fitness center, and event spaces that suit weddings and daytime business use.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle for a traditional, refined Upper East Side experience—historic pedigree, full-service spa, Bemelman's Bar and more formal dining options, and a quieter, more residential neighborhood near the Met and Madison Avenue.
Bottom line: both are upscale Manhattan choices serving sophisticated travelers; pick 1 Hotel Central Park for modern eco-luxe and Midtown convenience, or The Carlyle for classic style, history, and a more Upper East Side, club-like atmosphere.
| Category | 1 Hotel Central Park | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, eco-luxury design and reclaimed materials | Storied, Art Deco–era Upper East Side formality |
| Location | Steps from Central Park South and Midtown attractions (58th St & 6th Ave) | Upper East Side near Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size (rooms) | 229 guestrooms and suites | 188 guestrooms and suites |
| Building age / feel | Opened 2015; modern construction and finishes | Not published |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Jams (seasonal American/Californian) + lobby bar; in-room dining | Two restaurants including Bemelman's Bar; 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | No dedicated on-site spa; offers in-room wellness treatments and 24-hour Field House gym | Full-service spa on site; fitness facilities listed |
| Known for | Eco-design, reclaimed materials, proximity to Broadway and Midtown shopping | Historic New York clientele, celebrity history, Upper East Side address |
| Accessible transport | Multiple nearby subway lines and complimentary short-radius car service | Near Central Park and major museums; limo/town car service available |
| Family policy | Family-friendly; children welcome | |
1 Hotel Central Park sits at 1414 Avenue of the Americas, one block from Central Park South with quick walks to MoMA, Carnegie Hall, and Fifth Avenue shopping.
Pick 1 Hotel for Midtown sightseeing, shopping, and quick theater access with a Central Park edge.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street near Madison Avenue and the Metropolitan Museum of Art, in a quieter, more residential part of Manhattan.
Choose The Carlyle if you want museum-focused days and a quieter Upper East Side experience.
1 Hotel Central Park offers 229 rooms and suites with an eco-luxury aesthetic and reclaimed materials.
Expect modern layouts, sustainability touches, and several suite options with terraces and park views.
The Carlyle features classic luxury rooms and a wide selection of suites, reflecting its Rosewood positioning.
Pick The Carlyle for formal, traditional room types and many suite choices suited to longer or more private stays.
1 Hotel Central Park centers its dining around Jams, Chef Jonathan Waxman's all-day seasonal restaurant and lobby bar.
Choose 1 Hotel for contemporary seasonal cuisine in a relaxed, modern setting tied to the hotel's eco-style.
The Carlyle offers two restaurants and Bemelman's Bar, a well-known hotel lounge historically associated with the property.
The Carlyle fits travelers who prefer classic hotel dining and a formal bar with historical associations.
1 Hotel Central Park does not have an on-site pool but emphasizes fitness and event spaces.
Pick 1 Hotel if you prioritize a modern gym, rooftop/terrace event options, and park access over a hotel pool.
The Carlyle lists a full-service spa among its featured amenities and positions itself as a traditional, service-led luxury hotel.
Choose The Carlyle when an on-site spa and classic luxury services matter more than contemporary gym offerings.
1 Hotel Central Park focuses on round-the-clock fitness and a contemporary lobby bar with weekend brunch.
Great fit for guests who want to stay active at any hour and prefer modern, casual dining and bar scenes.
The Carlyle offers a quieter, more formal evening rhythm anchored by Bemelman's Bar and refined dining.
Best for travelers seeking refined evenings, late-night room service, and a more traditional hotel nightlife.

1 Hotel Central Park — reclaimed materials, bulk amenities, and visible living-green design elements.

The Carlyle — historic Upper East Side pedigree, Rosewood service, and a full-service spa.

1 Hotel Central Park — 24-hour Field House gym with Peloton bikes and group classes.

The Carlyle — very close to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Madison Avenue boutiques.
1 Hotel Central Park is in Midtown near MoMA, Carnegie Hall and Broadway; The Carlyle is farther east and better for museum days on the Upper East Side.
The Carlyle lists a full-service spa; 1 Hotel Central Park does not have a dedicated on-site spa and has no on-site pool. The Carlyle's pool status is not published in the supplier listing.
Yes. Both properties accept guests of all ages and are not adults-only hotels.
1 Hotel Central Park emphasizes sustainability in materials and operations and is the clearer choice for eco-minded travelers.
Explore how 1 Hotel Central Park stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·