
1 Hotel Central Park
Best for travelers who want a wellness-minded, sustainable Midtown base a block from Central Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
1 Hotel Central Park is an eco-minded, design-forward five-star hotel steps from Central Park, best for travelers who want sustainability, natural materials and easy access to Midtown green space. The New York EDITION is a design-led luxury hotel by Madison Square Park, aimed at guests who prefer fashion-forward interiors, a signature EDITION restaurant and a downtown Manhattan base.
Updated · about 1.9 miles (3.0 km) apart

Best for travelers who want a wellness-minded, sustainable Midtown base a block from Central Park.

Best for style-conscious guests who want a fashionable downtown location and EDITION brand dining and nightlife.
When 1 Hotel Central Park wins: choose 1 Hotel Central Park if proximity to Central Park, an eco-luxury aesthetic, pet-friendly policies, and a 24-hour fitness culture matter more than on-site spa or pool facilities.
When The New York EDITION wins: pick The New York EDITION if you prioritize an EDITION-design experience, a prominent signature restaurant and bars, more meeting/conference space, and a location around Madison Square Park.
Bottom line: both are five-star, design-forward Manhattan hotels; 1 Hotel Central Park leans green, park-adjacent and family-friendly, while The New York EDITION is a fashion-focused luxury choice nearer lower Midtown — your decision should hinge on whether Central Park access or the EDITION dining/scene matters more.
| Category | 1 Hotel Central Park | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Eco-conscious, natural-materials design; calm Midtown base | Design-led, fashion-forward luxury with EDITION brand style |
| Location | 1414 Avenue of the Americas — one block from Central Park South (Midtown) | 5 Madison Avenue — steps from Madison Square Park (Flatiron/Gramercy area) |
| Size (rooms) | 229 guest rooms and suites | 271 air-conditioned rooms |
| Ages / adults-only | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 18 | |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Jams — California-inspired American by Jonathan Waxman; lobby bar; in-room dining | The Clocktower restaurant; 2 bars/lounges; 24-hour room service |
| Spa / wellness | No dedicated on-site spa; in-room wellness services and 24-hour Field House fitness center | Onsite spa services and spa treatment room(s) + 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Meetings & events | Multiple event spaces including Full Floor (2,100 sq ft) and other indoor/outdoor venues | Conference space ~2,100 sq ft and 5 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility & practical | Complimentary Wi‑Fi, valet parking, EV charging, pet-friendly (dogs up to 40 lbs) | Complimentary Wi‑Fi, valet parking (surcharge), concierge, accessible facilities |
| Nearby highlights | Central Park, MoMA, Carnegie Hall, Fifth Avenue shopping | Madison Square Park, Flatiron Building, close to Empire State Building |
1 Hotel Central Park sits at Sixth Avenue and 58th Street, a block from Central Park South.
Choose 1 Hotel Central Park for immediate Central Park access and classic Midtown sightseeing.
The New York EDITION is at 5 Madison Avenue, steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron District.
Pick The New York EDITION for a downtown-leaning location with easy access to Flatiron and Gramercy-area restaurants and shops.
Rooms at 1 Hotel Central Park emphasize reclaimed materials and eco-minded features across 229 rooms.
Rooms focus on eco-luxury finishes and practical amenities for Midtown stays.
The New York EDITION offers 271 air-conditioned rooms with Smart TVs and minibars in a design-focused package.
The EDITION emphasizes polished room design, comfort elements and a broad mix of accessible room types.
Jams at 1 Hotel Central Park is an all-day restaurant by Jonathan Waxman with a lobby bar and patio seating.
Jams is a home-base restaurant with seasonal, California-inspired American menus and a relaxed bar scene.
The New York EDITION features The Clocktower restaurant plus two bars and 24-hour room service.
The EDITION provides a stronger late-night/drinks program and multiple on-site bars alongside a signature restaurant.
1 Hotel Central Park’s standout amenity is The Field House fitness center and its proximity to Central Park.
If fitness access and park-based outdoor activity matter, 1 Hotel Central Park has a clear focus despite no pool or spa.
The New York EDITION pairs 24-hour fitness facilities with onsite spa services and multiple meeting rooms.
The EDITION leans more toward a full-service luxury hotel for meetings and in-house spa treatments.
Wellness at 1 Hotel Central Park centers on fitness, in-room wellness options and contact with Central Park.
Expect a wellness-forward, active stay rather than spa-and-pool relaxation.
The New York EDITION combines traditional spa treatments with an active bar and lounge scene.
The EDITION is the stronger choice for guests who want in-hotel spa services and an evening scene.

1 Hotel Central Park — one block from Central Park South and easy access to park trails and attractions.

The New York EDITION — signature EDITION design, The Clocktower restaurant and two bars/lounges.

The New York EDITION — supplier listing shows 5 meeting rooms and ~2,100 sq ft of conference space.

1 Hotel Central Park — reclaimed materials, living green wall and sustainability-focused in-room amenities.
1 Hotel Central Park — it’s a one-block (about a 2-minute) walk from Central Park South.
The New York EDITION lists onsite spa services; 1 Hotel Central Park does not have a dedicated on-site spa or a pool.
Yes — both welcome guests of all ages; neither is an adults-only property.
The New York EDITION — it has two bars/lounges and a stronger late-night dining/drinks program on site.
Both hotels offer complimentary Wi‑Fi and 24-hour fitness facilities.
Explore how 1 Hotel Central Park stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·